The Entry Fee
To publish on the App Store you join the Apple Developer Program, which costs $99 a year for an individual or organisation. It is not a one-off: stop paying and your apps leave the store. Add a Mac to build on, and a device or two to test on, and the cost of simply being allowed to ship is real before you have written a line of product code. Google charges a one-time registration fee of $25. The two prices say something about how each store thinks about small developers.
The Rejection You Cannot Argue With
Apple's App Review Guidelines contain a section on spam (4.3). Besides forbidding clones and duplicate apps, it says reviewers may reject apps for a category that already has an excess of similar apps. Read that again: the problem is not that your app is broken, unsafe or dishonest. The problem is that there are already apps like it.
As a rule that sounds sensible, because stores do fill with near-identical clones. As an indie developer it is a hard one to live with, because it is a judgement about a market, not a defect you can fix. You cannot patch "too many apps like this". The usual advice is to explain what is genuinely different about your product and resubmit, which means the review depends on how well a human reads your explanation.
Why This Hurts Small Teams Most
- Unpredictable: the same idea can pass for one developer and fail for another, and the reason is often a short message.
- Slow feedback: a rejection costs days, and a mistake in your explanation costs days more.
- The fee is paid either way: the $99 does not buy a guarantee of approval.
- The commission continues: the standard rate is 30%, or 15% under the Small Business Program for developers earning under $1 million a year.
What I Do About It
Opinions are cheap, so here is the practical side. I build the web version first, because the web has no gatekeeper: SUTOK and AI Exodus both run in a browser as well as on Android. A product that already works on the open web is a much stronger position to negotiate a store review from, and a store rejection never takes the whole product offline.
- Write down, before you submit, what is different about your app in two plain sentences.
- Do not build five near-identical apps with different themes; that is exactly what the rule targets.
- Keep your core product reachable outside any single store.
None of this makes the fee or the uncertainty fair. It just means your business does not depend on one reviewer's afternoon. Need help planning a launch across web and stores? Send me a request.